The Cruelest Lie

"For God doth know that in the day ye eat thereof, then your eyes shall be opened, and ye shall be as gods, knowing good and evil." - Genesis 3:5

The serpent's words to Eve in the Garden of Eden have echoed throughout human history, but perhaps we've misunderstood what they truly meant. This wasn't just a promise of knowing—it was a deception that would fundamentally alter humanity's relationship with God and truth itself.

Made in God's Image, Yet Deceived

Earlier in Genesis, we learn that humanity was created in the image of God—something inherently God-adjacent, bearing divine likeness. The serpent understood this perfectly. When he approached Eve, he wasn't elevating humanity to a higher plane; he was knocking them down to a level where he could easily reach them. His temptation was designed to exploit the very thing that made humans special: their unique position between the divine and created realms.

To understand the serpent’s true strategy, we must examine what he offered: not intelligence, but independence.

The True Nature of Moral Knowledge

For years, I believed the forbidden fruit was primarily about intelligence or wisdom. I thought it was about becoming smarter, more enlightened. But as I studied Genesis 3:5 more deeply, I realized something far more profound. The issue wasn’t intelligence—Adam and Eve already had access to knowledge. The real issue was moral authority: the rightful power to define good and evil and to expect others to align with that standard. That authority belongs to God alone. Humanity was never meant to define morality, only to receive it through intimate relationship with Him, the source of all truth.

History bears witness to the catastrophic results when finite, imperfect humans attempt to wield that authority. From fallen empires built on twisted definitions of leadership and justice, to wars justified by competing moral systems, to genocides rationalized through human reasoning—the wreckage of autonomous moral decision-making litters human history. Each generation believing it has finally figured it out, only to create new flavors of human suffering.

We chose to become autonomous moral agents—relying on our own compass, without the wisdom, eternal perspective, or moral perfection needed to navigate a world we did not create. And in doing so, we became less human.

The Paradox of Fallen Knowledge

In trying to rise to God’s level, we descended into confusion and created a world that has become a prison.

We weren’t elevated by our moral independence. We were condemned to learn good and evil through experience and evolution—through trial and error. And that process inevitably diminishes our humanity. It causes us to sin and inflicts damage on ourselves and others. Guilt, shame, fear, anxiety, and pain become inevitable outcomes.

Even when we do discover truth through this painful method, pride often leads us further from God. We begin to trust results instead of the One who founded the earth by wisdom and established the heavens by understanding (Proverbs 3:19). We develop an addiction to evidence-based truth rather than a trust-based relationship with God.

The Innocence of Trust

As illustrated by our humble beginnings, there’s a profound innocence required to live without needing to “know good and evil”—a childlike innocence that trusts God’s wisdom. As Deuteronomy 1:39 reminds us, there is a state of being where we can follow God without the burden and consequences of autonomous moral decision-making.

Adam and Eve experienced paradise firsthand. They saw what trust in God provided: protection, provision, and access to the divine. They lived in perfect harmony with their Creator. Can you imagine that kind of place?

God's Design for Moral Discernment

This doesn’t mean God intends us to remain naive forever. As we mature in Him, we are invited into discernment (1 Kings 3:9)—but this discernment flows from relationship, not separation. It comes through His Word, His Spirit, and divine communion—not painful experience.

And we’ve seen what happens to those who reverse God’s definitions—calling evil good and good evil (Isaiah 5:20), exchanging the truth of God for a lie (Romans 1:25). That path doesn’t lead to understanding, but to despair.

Jesus: The Reversal of the Fall

This is where Christ’s role becomes beautifully clear. Jesus never sinned, yet He possessed perfect knowledge of good and evil. He demonstrates what humanity was meant to be—fully human, yet perfectly aligned with divine authority.

Jesus reverses the Fall not only by forgiving sin, but by restoring our ability to know what is good without having to taste evil. David understood this when he wrote: “Oh, taste and see that the LORD is good! Blessed is the man who takes refuge in Him.” (Psalm 34:8). Notice how this involves a multi-sensory invitation—we can taste God’s goodness, see the fruit of it, and live within its shelter. In Christ, we gain wisdom without self-destruction.

Returning to Paradise

The serpent’s lie promised that we could be like God through autonomous knowledge. The gospel reveals that we can be like God through restored relationship—not as independent moral agents, but as sons and daughters who trust their Father’s perfect wisdom.

God doesn’t want us to know what is good through separation and pain. He wants us to know good through communion with Him—the source of all goodness. In Christ, we find not just forgiveness for our failures, but restoration to what was lost in the Garden: the ability to know good not through our own understanding (Proverbs 3:5), but through His infinite wisdom and love.

The serpent’s promise led to exile. God’s promise leads us home.

Final Reflection

What would change in your life if you truly believed you could know good and evil not through painful experience, but through relationship with the One who is goodness itself?

Would you live with less fear? Less striving? Would you finally trust instead of needing to prove everything first?

Next
Next

The Weight of Grace